Compare renting vs buying over 5 and 7 years
See your estimated net position for each option based on rent, property growth and mortgage.
Assumed return if you invest your deposit while renting.
Net financial position after 5 and 7 years (estimates only)
Break-even: year 5
On these assumptions the buyer's net worth overtakes the renter's in year 5 and stays ahead for the rest of the 30 years modelled.
If you buy
Property value: $973,322
Loan balance: $597,001
Interest paid so far: $192,189
Ongoing costs: $25,000
Net position: $376,321
$332,613 in today's dollars
If you rent
Rent paid so far: $165,645
Deposit and upfront costs, invested: $262,187
Buyer's outlay minus your rent, invested: $107,456
Net position: $369,643
$326,711 in today's dollars
If you buy
Property value: $1,052,745
Loan balance: $575,716
Interest paid so far: $264,980
Ongoing costs: $35,000
Net position: $477,029
$401,308 in today's dollars
If you rent
Rent paid so far: $239,069
Deposit and upfront costs, invested: $295,150
Buyer's outlay minus your rent, invested: $152,585
Net position: $447,735
$376,664 in today's dollars
Both sides are shown as wealth on the same basis. Buying = the property’s value less what you still owe. Renting = your deposit and the upfront costs you never paid, invested, plus the difference each year between the buyer’s outlay and your rent, invested at the same return. Charging the buyer their repayments and crediting the renter the money they did not spend are the same calculation; showing only one of them is what made an earlier version of this page favour buying. Two modelling choices matter more than they look: the renter's savings are invested at the END of each year, and ongoing costs are held flat while rent grows. Investing at the start of each year instead moves the break-even out by a year on these defaults; escalating ongoing costs with rent narrows the margin without moving the year. Treat the year as a guide and vary the inputs. Net positions are in future dollars; the today's-dollars line under each converts it back at the inflation rate ASIC sets for these calculators. This is a simplified model. It does not deduct tax on the renter’s investment returns, selling costs, lenders mortgage insurance or any vacancy, and it applies property growth to the whole property while the renter earns a return on their savings alone. Actual outcomes depend on many factors. Not financial advice.
This calculator is not intended to be relied on for the purposes of making a decision in relation to a financial product. Before you make a financial decision, consider obtaining advice from someone who holds an Australian Financial Services Licence. We do not, and we cannot advise you.
The rent vs buy decision depends on your personal circumstances, local property prices and how long you plan to stay. There's no single right answer.
Buying builds equity and offers stability, but comes with large upfront costs (stamp duty, legal fees) and ongoing expenses (maintenance, rates, insurance). Renting offers flexibility and lower upfront costs, but rent increases over time and you don't build property equity.
Typically 5–7 years to break even on upfront costs, though this varies with property growth and interest rates. Use this calculator to see your specific scenario.
Not necessarily. Rent pays for housing, just like mortgage interest pays for access to bank money. The question is whether you're better off building equity in property or investing elsewhere.
Property prices, rents, interest rates and your timeframe all affect the comparison. Different assumptions can produce different outcomes, so the result reflects the inputs selected in this calculator.
Estimates only. Not financial or tax advice. Full disclaimer for your rights and our limitations of liability.
This calculator exists to show you the arithmetic. It applies published Australian rates, thresholds and formulas to the numbers you enter and shows the working, so you can check it. That is all it does — it produces a number and describes what the number is. It does not recommend anything and it holds no opinion about any financial product.
What can move this result
Why these default assumptions are reasonable
This calculator is not intended to be relied on for the purposes of making a decision in relation to a financial product. Before you make a financial decision, consider obtaining advice from someone who holds an Australian Financial Services Licence. We do not, and we cannot advise you.